Alaska
How Will the New Trump Mail-In Voting Strategy Impact Bennington County?
President Donald Trump wants to sharply curtail mail ballots. He’s called them “inherently corrupt” and baselessly condemned them as a major source of fraud. But with Republicans falling behind in the polls, the president is now urging his supporters to…
Last updated:
Key points
- President Trump has reversed his stance and is now encouraging supporters to vote early and by mail ahead of the midterms.
- The shift comes as national polls show Democrats holding a double-digit lead on the generic congressional ballot.
- Election experts say securing early mail-in votes is critical for campaigns to efficiently allocate their resources.
NewsWK — Southern Vermont voters are preparing for the upcoming midterms. Meanwhile, a major shift in national political strategy is making waves in Bennington County. President Donald Trump has reversed his long-standing opposition to mail-in ballots. Instead, he now actively encourages supporters to use any legal method to vote.
This change could reshape local campaigns. Therefore, local election officials are preparing for a busy voting season.
How does the shift in Trump mail-in voting affect Southern Vermont campaigns?
This rhetorical shift directly impacts political organizers in Bennington, Shaftsbury, and Pownal. In fact, Vermont already sends mail-in ballots to all registered voters. However, local Republicans have historically lagged behind in early returns. As a result, the new national guidance could help local GOP candidates close that turnout gap before Election Day.
For years, mixed messages from national leaders complicated the local GOP mail-in voting strategy. In Bennington County, many conservative voters avoided mail-in ballots due to previous warnings about fraud. Now, local party organizers can promote early voting freely. Furthermore, they can do so without conflicting with national messaging.
Similarly, this shift affects neighboring communities. In Rensselaer County, New York, and Berkshire County, Massachusetts, voters face different early voting rules. However, the overarching message remains the same across state lines. In short, campaigns want their supporters to secure their votes as early as possible.
As Trump urges early voting across conservative states, local organizers hope for a similar bump. A mail-in ballot provides a guaranteed vote. In fact, political scientists refer to these early ballots as a “bird in the hand.” Once a supporter votes early, the campaign stops sending them mailers. Consequently, organizers can focus limited resources on undecided voters instead.
Why did the president change his stance on mail-in ballots?
President Trump shifted his approach because Republicans face a challenging landscape in upcoming midterm elections. Recent polling shows Democrats holding an 11-point lead on the generic ballot. Therefore, the White House chose to prioritize voter turnout over past consistency. This pragmatic move aims to mobilize base voters nationwide.
Recent national polls clearly highlight these challenges for the Republican party. For instance, an Emerson College poll from September showed Democrats with an 11-point advantage on the generic congressional ballot. Furthermore, the poll found that 78 percent of Democrats felt very excited to vote. In contrast, only 66 percent of Republicans shared that high level of excitement.
Meanwhile, a New York Times and Siena College poll showed tight Senate races in several conservative states. These states include Alaska, Kansas, Ohio, and Texas. Notably, many of these states allow voters to cast mail-in ballots without needing an excuse.
Because of these tight numbers, national Republican leaders are scrambling to maximize turnout. Political science professor Brandon Rottinghaus noted that the party must use every legal tool available.
“The overriding concern for the White House is turnout, not consistency,” Rottinghaus said.
What legal battles preceded this shift in the GOP mail-in voting strategy?
Before this sudden embrace of early voting, the administration tried to limit mail-in ballots through federal regulations. The U.S. Supreme Court ultimately blocked that executive order. If enacted, the order would have allowed the Postal Service to reject ballots from non-compliant states during the election cycle.
Earlier, in August 2025, Trump promised to lead a movement to eliminate mail-in voting. He later signed an executive order directing the U.S. Postal Service to enforce strict rules on states. Specifically, the rule required states to notify the Postal Service of their mail plans 90 days before an election.
However, the U.S. Supreme Court blocked the controversial rule in September. Prior to that ruling, election officials warned that the rule would have caused widespread chaos.
In addition, civic groups strongly opposed the measure. Celina Stewart, president of the League of Women Voters, emphasized that
“the President does not have the authority to unilaterally dictate how states administer elections.”
In fact, her organization had sued to stop the executive order.
How popular is mail-in voting across the country today?
Despite ongoing political debates, mail-in voting has become a permanent fixture for millions of American voters. During the 2024 election, nearly one-third of all voters cast mail ballots. In addition, early participation remains exceptionally high this year as voters across the country request tens of millions of early ballots.
How will this change affect the Republican voter turnout midterms?
The push to embrace early voting aims to boost Republican midterm voter turnout in critical swing districts. Campaign experts note that early mail-in ballots bank guaranteed votes ahead of time. As a result, campaigns can preserve vital energy and redirect scarce outreach dollars toward undecided swing voters.
Nationwide, mail-in voting continues to show strong popularity among the electorate. During the 2024 election, nearly one-third of all American voters cast their ballots by mail. Today, that preference remains clear.
So far, nearly 1 million people have already voted by mail in the general election. Additionally, voters have requested more than 52 million mail ballots nationwide.
Here is what you need to know about mail-in voting in our region:
- Vermont: All registered voters automatically receive a mail-in ballot. You can return it by mail or drop it off at your town clerk’s office.
- New York: Voters in Hoosick and White Creek must request an absentee ballot or vote early in person.
- Massachusetts: Voters in Williamstown and North Adams can vote early by mail or in person.
Ultimately, this shift in rhetoric from national leaders could change how local voters behave. Local town clerks in Bennington County stand ready to process these ballots securely. Therefore, they encourage all residents to make a voting plan early.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team.
Sources
Related: Supreme Court Mail-In Ballot Ruling Bennington: Regional Impact and What to Know
Related: USPS Mail-in Voting Whistleblower Warns of Ballot Delays
Related: Trump Midterm Election Interference Fears Prompt Local Security Prep
See a typo? Report it here.
