Arlington
Kyle Kapitanski Shelburne Police Officer Decertified After Fatal Crash
A state panel did leave open the possibility that the ex-officer could reapply for certification after a year. Read the story on VTDigger here: Fired Shelburne police sergeant stripped of police certification for role in deadly crash.
Last updated:
Key points
- The Vermont Criminal Justice Council revoked former Shelburne police sergeant Kyle Kapitanski’s law enforcement certification for at least one year.
- Kapitanski previously pleaded guilty to misdemeanor negligent operation after striking and killing cyclist Sean Hayes in 2024.
- State regulators confirmed that any future recertification would require board approval and full academy retraining.
Montpelier, Vt. NewsWK — State regulators took action this week against a former police sergeant. He was involved in a fatal 2024 vehicle collision. This decision carries clear implications for oversight, officer conduct, and police cruiser safety across Vermont.
How did the Vermont Criminal Justice Council handle the Kyle Kapitanski Shelburne police case?
The Vermont Criminal Justice Council approved a settlement regarding former officer Kyle Kapitanski. Specifically, the deal revokes his law enforcement certification. Under this agreement, Kapitanski surrenders his license for at least one year. Any future recertification remains entirely at the discretion of the state council.
The panel’s action resolves administrative proceedings without a public disciplinary hearing. Members of the state panel approved the deal during their regular meeting. Additionally, officials confirmed that Kapitanski did not submit a public statement regarding the decision.
What does the Shelburne police sergeant decertified outcome mean for Vermont departments?
This disciplinary decision establishes a clear standard for municipal police departments. It impacts agencies across Southern Vermont and Bennington County. Therefore, local law enforcement agencies must enforce strict rules regarding distracted driving in patrol cars. When officers violate safety protocols, state action directly removes their law enforcement authority.
Municipal leaders in Bennington, Manchester, and Arlington pay close attention to state oversight board rulings. Local departments rely on clear standards to maintain public trust. Therefore, state action in high-profile cases reinforces daily safety rules for all officers on patrol. Ultimately, distracted driving regulations apply to police officers just like any other driver.
What caused the Kyle Kapitanski crash on Shelburne Road?
The fatal incident occurred early in the morning on November 11, 2024. It Happened Along Shelburne Road in South Burlington. At the time, Kapitanski drove his patrol cruiser between 40 and 45 mph in a 35 mph speed zone. Meanwhile, 38-year-old cyclist Sean Hayes was walking his bicycle along the roadside. Then, the cruiser hit him.
Court documents detailed critical factors leading up to the deadly impact. For instance, investigators discovered that Kapitanski had YouTube videos playing before the crash. These videos played on a tablet mounted in his cruiser. Tragically, the collision killed Hayes.
Prosecutors subsequently charged Kapitanski in Chittenden Superior Criminal Court in Burlington. In September 2025, Kapitanski entered a plea agreement. Specifically, he pleaded guilty to misdemeanor negligent operation of a motor vehicle with death resulting. The judge sentenced him to six to 12 months in jail, all suspended. He also received two years of probation.
The town of Shelburne fired Kapitanski shortly after he entered his guilty plea. Previously, he had remained on paid administrative leave since the date of the crash.
What steps must occur before a Vermont Criminal Justice Council recertification vote?
Reinstating a revoked license requires a multi-step process under state regulations. First, Kapitanski must petition the state board for permission to reapply. He can only do this after his one-year revocation ends. Next, he must complete the full police academy training program again. The board could grant a rare waiver.
Christopher Perkett serves as associate general counsel for the state council. He explained the legal steps to board members during the meeting. Furthermore, Perkett noted that requesting a training waiver is extremely rare and that the council has never had this happen before. Returning to active police work would require substantial formal review.
How did the victim’s family react to the Sean Hayes Shelburne crash resolution?
Relatives of the victim expressed deep grief over the loss. They also strongly opposed any future police career for Kapitanski. Following the vote, Donna Hayes addressed the state council directly. During her remarks, she shared personal details about her son’s life and his goals. She also described the immense loss felt by his family.
Donna Hayes spoke passionately to board members after they finalized the agreement. “I want everybody to know he had a family,” Donna Hayes told the council. “He has people who love and care about him.”
She noted that her son was attending college when he died. Remarkably, Sean Hayes had hoped to become a police officer himself. Therefore, his mother urged the panel never to restore the former sergeant’s badge. “I don’t think he should ever be certified in law enforcement again,” Donna Hayes said.
What is the timeline of events in this case?
The legal and administrative process following the fatal collision stretched over two years. Specifically, key developments include the initial investigation and Criminal Court sentencing. Job termination and final state decertification followed. Overall, this timeline highlights how criminal and administrative oversight systems function alongside each other in Vermont.
Here are the key milestones in the case:
- November 11, 2024: A Shelburne police cruiser strikes and kills cyclist Sean Hayes in South Burlington.
- September 2025: Kyle Kapitanski pleads guilty to misdemeanor negligent operation with death resulting.
- Fall 2025: The Town of Shelburne terminates Kapitanski from the police department.
- Late 2026: The state council revokes Kapitanski’s law enforcement certification for at least one year.
What does this mean for Southern Vermont communities?
Public safety Officials Across Bennington County continuously update vehicle safety standards. They also review distracted driving policies. Consequently, the resolution of this case sends a clear message to departments in Pownal, Shaftsbury, and Manchester. State authorities will enforce strict accountability when officers break traffic laws on duty.
Local residents expect high standards from all sworn law enforcement officers in Vermont. Therefore, computer screens, tablets, and mobile devices in patrol cars require careful policy management. Meanwhile, state regulators continue to enforce license revocations. As a result, local departments will keep reviewing internal safety procedures to protect pedestrians and cyclists.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team.
Sources
Related: Vermont State Police Shaftsbury Barracks Investigates Fatal Crash in Southern Vermont
Related: Vermont State Police Shaftsbury Crash Under Investigation by Troopers
See a typo? Report it here.


