Bennington
Local Response to AG’s Decision on Putney Shooting Case
Police killed Scott Garvey in his Putney home where he was experiencing a mental health crisis. “Is the state going to hold anyone accountable at all? Or is this just a free ride, a free pass?” his brother said. Read…
Last updated:
Key points
- Vermont Attorney General will not prosecute a state trooper involved in the fatal shooting of Scott Garvey in Putney.
- The incident raises concerns about police accountability and mental health crisis management in Bennington County.
- Local residents may push for improved mental health resources and police training following this case.
MONTPELIER, Vt. NewsWK — The decision by Vermont Attorney General Charity Clark not to prosecute a state trooper involved in the fatal shooting of an unarmed man in Putney has sparked concern among residents in Bennington and the surrounding communities. Scott Garvey, a 55-year-old man experiencing a mental health crisis, was shot by Trooper Peter Romeo in July 2025 after a prolonged standoff at Garvey’s home.
Incident Overview
According to a press release from the Attorney General’s office, police responded to a report of Garvey barricading himself in his apartment for over four hours. On July 7, 2025, Trooper Romeo fatally shot Garvey after he allegedly pointed an object—later identified as a metal pole—toward the officers. The investigation revealed that Garvey had a history of schizophrenia and had voiced concerns about potential threats from neighbors prior to the incident.
Community Impact
This incident raises significant questions for local residents in Bennington County regarding police accountability and mental health crisis management. With a history of police shootings in Vermont resulting in no criminal prosecutions, many are left wondering how this case reflects on local law enforcement practices. Shawn Garvey, Scott’s brother, expressed his belief that the tragedy could have been avoided and questioned whether there will be any accountability for the officers involved.
Statements from Officials
In a statement, Attorney General Clark acknowledged the pain experienced by the Garvey family, calling the event a tragedy. “We cannot imagine the pain that the Garvey family has endured and continues to experience, and our hearts go out to them during this time,” she said.
Next Steps for the Community
As residents of Bennington reflect on this situation, discussions surrounding mental health resources and police training may become more prominent. Local agencies could consider how to improve responses to mental health crises, ensuring that similar incidents do not occur in the future.
This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team.
Based on reporting originally published by VTDigger. Read the original story.
