Skip to content
Connect with us

Bennington, VT News

Michelle Mullins Sentencing Hartford VT: 6-Month Term Ordered

Mullins was sentenced to six months in prison for her role in a fatal Hartford robbery, agreeing to testify against the alleged shooter. Read the story on VTDigger here: Michelle Mullins receives 6-month prison sentence in Hartford shooting case.

Michelle Mullins Sentencing Hartford VT: 6-Month Term Ordered

Published

on

Attorney and woman stand before judge in wood-paneled courtroom. — Michelle Mullins Sentencing Hartford VT
Bennington, VT News

Michelle Mullins Sentencing Hartford VT: 6-Month Term Ordered

Mullins was sentenced to six months in prison for her role in a fatal Hartford robbery, agreeing to testify against the alleged shooter. Read the story on VTDigger here: Michelle Mullins receives 6-month prison sentence in Hartford shooting case.

PlanIT

Last updated:

Key points

  • Michelle Mullins received a six-month prison sentence in Windsor Superior Court for her role in an attempted robbery that turned fatal.
  • The reduced sentence relies on Mullins testifying against alleged gunman Demetrius Drew during his upcoming murder trial.
  • Surviving victim Jessica Lemay expressed deep grief and frustration over the plea bargains granted to the accomplices.

MONTPELIER, Vt. — Court proceedings in Windsor County brought a major development in a tragic regional case this week. Also, a Windsor Superior Court judge delivered a six-month prison term to a Vermont woman. She had a role in a fatal attempted robbery. Ultimately, this outcome underscores how prosecutors use plea agreements to pursue justice in serious criminal cases across Vermont.

What Happened at the Windsor Superior Court Sentencing?

Windsor Superior Court sentencing proceedings on Friday delivered a six-month prison term for Michelle Mullins. The penalty follows her role in a fatal August 2025 attempted robbery. Mullins pleaded guilty to a lesser charge. In exchange, prosecutors suspended a longer prison term for her full cooperation against the alleged gunman.

Michelle Mullins, 47, stood before the court on Friday afternoon to receive her penalty. Previously, she agreed to plead guilty to felony accessory to attempted assault and robbery. Under the court agreement, Judge Elizabeth Mann handed down a sentence of six to 10 years. However, the court suspended all but six months of that period. Mullins must also complete 12 years of probation.

During the hearing, Mullins addressed surviving victim Jessica Lemay in the courtroom gallery. “I know you think I don’t care or feel,” Mullins said through tears. “But I want you to know I am so sorry.”

Lemay did not look back at Mullins during the apology. Instead, Lemay shared her ongoing grief when speaking to the court. “The punishment doesn’t fit the crime,” Lemay stated, repeating her past objections to the plea deals. She then added, “Every day, I wake up in the aftermath.”

Why Did the Hartford VT Shooting Case Deal Include Reduced Prison Time?

State prosecutors structured the Hartford VT shooting case plea deal to secure essential testimony against the primary suspect. By offering reduced sentences to accomplices, state officials aim to build a stronger prosecution. Specifically, they want solid evidence against the alleged shooter when his case goes to trial.

The state attorney general’s office emphasized that co-defendant testimony remains vital to the homicide case. Prosecutor Nicholas Battey explained that the reduced sentence directly depends on Mullins testifying against the accused shooter, Demetrius Drew. Judge Mann acknowledged that the sentence fell below typical expectations for such cases. Still, she noted the sealed cooperation agreement justifies the outcome.

Furthermore, the deal carries strict conditions. Because Mullins agreed to cooperate, prosecutors dismissed the first-degree murder accessory charge. However, if Mullins fails to testify truthfully, prosecutors can refile that original charge. That severe charge carries a potential life sentence in prison.

Meanwhile, Mullins’ husband, Jeffrey Mullins, received a similar six-month prison sentence in September. He also agreed to testify for the state under his own plea deal. Both individuals originally faced severe penalties before accepting their respective agreements.

How Does the Michelle Mullins Sentence Impact Victims and Local Communities?

Decisions surrounding Michelle Mullins and her co-defendants highlight a complicated emotional reality for violent crime victims in Vermont. Court resolutions often balance victim grief with prosecutorial strategy. Consequently, these legal outcomes shape public confidence in the regional justice system.

For residents in White River Junction and nearby areas, violent incidents leave lasting scars on local neighborhoods. The crime disrupted peaceful residential streets and deeply affected families across state lines. Lemay and her late boyfriend, David Labrecque, shared a home in Canaan, New Hampshire. worked as a mechanic, while Lemay was launching a home cleaning business.

Therefore, the emotional toll remains heavy for Survivors During Every Court appearance. Lemay expressed her frustration with the Continuous Court process. She told the court she never expected to navigate such tragic circumstances.

Additionally, Background Court records reveal that Michelle Mullins faces separate legal issues. She has a pending felony drug possession charge in Grafton County, New Hampshire. That charge stems from an incident in Lebanon, New Hampshire, occurring two months prior to the Hartford shooting.

What Is the Background of the White River Junction VT Shooting?

The fatal White River Junction VT shooting took place early on Aug. 21, 2025, outside a Verna Court residence. David Labrecque died attempting to shield his girlfriend, Jessica Lemay, from an armed attacker. The confrontation began as an attempted robbery that quickly escalated into gunfire.

Police reports detail the violent sequence of events on that August morning. First, an armed man wearing a bandana confronted Lemay outside the residence and opened fire. Hearing the gunfire, Labrecque rushed outside to protect her. Then, the assailant shot Labrecque in the chest and back, killing him at the scene. Lemay also sustained serious injuries to her abdomen and hand during the attack.

Investigators later identified 31-year-old Demetrius Drew of New Haven, Connecticut, as the alleged gunman. Moreover, police gathered key evidence from the area. This included security camera footage showing Drew near the crime scene shortly after the shooting. Drew pleaded not guilty to multiple charges, including first-degree murder and attempted robbery.

What to expect as the legal proceedings continue:

  • The court scheduled a pretrial conference and jury selection for Demetrius Drew in February.
  • State prosecutors expect both Michelle and Jeffrey Mullins to testify during Drew’s trial.
  • Authorities continue holding Drew at Southern State Correctional Facility in Springfield, Vermont.

Recently, Drew submitted handwritten motions from jail seeking a new bail hearing and witness impeachment. However, Judge Mann ruled that the court will only accept motions filed through defense counsel. In addition, Drew filed a civil lawsuit against prison staff regarding a drug test dispute.

Meanwhile, local authorities continue working to ensure justice for the victims. Communities Across Windsor County and Southern Vermont monitor these proceedings closely as the trial date approaches.

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team.

Sources

Related: Supreme Court Revives Deven Moffitt Murder Case in Bennington County

Related: Deven Moffitt Vermont Supreme Court Ruling Reopens Searsburg Murder Case

Wedding RSVP
See a typo? Report it here.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *