Skip to content
Connect with us

Bennington, VT News

Final Prison Terms Handed Down in Fort Ann Double Homicide Sentencing

Three Albany men received state prison sentences for their roles in the May 2025 double homicide of two Glens Falls teenagers in Fort Ann. The Washington County Court proceedings concluded a lengthy investigation into the fatal Clay Hill Road robbery.

Final Prison Terms Handed Down in Fort Ann Double Homicide Sentencing

Published

on

Illustration of Fort Ann double homicide sentencing, with men in orange uniforms before a judge in court.
Bennington, VT News

Final Prison Terms Handed Down in Fort Ann Double Homicide Sentencing

Three Albany men received state prison sentences for their roles in the May 2025 double homicide of two Glens Falls teenagers in Fort Ann. The Washington County Court proceedings concluded a lengthy investigation into the fatal Clay Hill Road robbery.

Trade Dispatch Story sidebar

Two Albany men received state prison terms Friday for a fatal double shooting in Washington County. The court proceedings mark the conclusion of a tragic homicide case. The case impacted communities from Glens Falls to Bennington.

What occurred at the Fort Ann double homicide sentencing?

On Friday, Judge Kelly S. McKeighan sentenced shooter David M. LaRose to 24 years to life in prison. Meanwhile, co-defendant Jordan P. Johnson received 18 years to life. Both Albany men previously admitted to their roles in the fatal May 2025 shooting on Clay Hill Road in Fort Ann.

The Friday Court session finalized prosecutions against three Albany residents involved in the killings. In October 2025, LaRose, 20, pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder under a plea agreement. During his allocution, LaRose admitted he fired the fatal shots during an attempted robbery. He also acknowledged that his co-defendants knew he carried a handgun.

Johnson, who was 18 at his arrest, also pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder. Earlier in November, Judge McKeighan sentenced the third defendant, 17-year-old Nasire Nelson, to 15 years to life. Nelson was 17 when the crimes occurred. Consequently, Washington County District Attorney Tony Jordan noted the prison terms reflected each defendant’s specific involvement.

What led to the Fatal Washington County NY double homicide?

The deadly May 22, 2025 confrontation stemmed from a planned gun transaction on Clay Hill Road. Three Albany teens traveled to Fort Ann. However, the meeting turned into an attempted robbery. As a result, two 19-year-old Glens Falls teenagers were shot and killed.

Emergency responders received reports of gunfire on Clay Hill Road around 9 p.m. New York State Police troopers and Washington County Sheriff’s deputies arrived quickly at the scene. They found Adam M. Darrah, 19, and Marcus J. Macaulay, 19, lying in the roadway with severe gunshot wounds. First responders transported both victims to Glens Falls Hospital. Medical staff pronounced them dead later that evening.

Furthermore, court records show that Darrah and Macaulay went to the meeting location. When the Albany group attempted to steal the property, LaRose drew his firearm and shot both young men. District Attorney Tony Jordan called LaRose’s sentence appropriate because he pulled the trigger. Jordan noted this held true despite LaRose’s lack of a prior criminal record.

How did police resolve the Fort Ann NY double homicide investigation? Fort Ann Double Homicide

Law enforcement agencies rapidly tracked down all three suspects in the hours following the shooting. State Police worked alongside local police departments across the Capital Region to apprehend the fleeing teenagers safely. Effective multi-agency coordination proved vital to securing key evidence and swift arrests shortly after the crime.

Specifically, Troy Police officers assisted State Police in arresting LaRose at 12:48 a.m. on May 23, 2025. Then, Albany Police located and arrested Johnson around 10 p.m. that same night. Finally, officers apprehended Nelson the following month after completing further investigative work.

How does the Fort Ann shooting sentencing affect regional community safety?

The conclusion of this murder case offers legal resolution to grieving Families Across Washington County and neighboring regions. Local officials emphasized that violent gun crimes bring severe legal consequences. Moreover, the case highlights ongoing efforts by regional law enforcement agencies to combat armed robberies in quiet local towns.

The tragedy affected many residents in Glens Falls and surrounding area communities who knew the victims. Below are key milestones established during the police investigation and court proceedings:

  • May 22, 2025: Darrah and Macaulay suffered fatal gunshot wounds on Clay Hill Road in Fort Ann.
  • May 23, 2025: Authorities arrested LaRose in Troy and Johnson in Albany.
  • October 2025: Defendants entered guilty pleas to murder charges in Washington County Court.
  • November 2026: Judge McKeighan sentenced the final two co-defendants to state prison.

Consequently, all three perpetrators will serve significant prison terms before becoming eligible for parole consideration.

Sources

This article was produced with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team.

Related: Supreme Court Revives Deven Moffitt Murder Case in Bennington County

Related: New York Prison ‘Contraband Watch’ Practices Draw Fire Over Conditions

Wedding RSVP
See a typo? Report it here.